Abstract reviewing

Review conference contributions with your scientific committee

We set up the review process for your event, from reviewer access and assessment guidelines to feedback for authors. Assessments, PDF annotations, and revisions stay attached to the contribution. Your scientific committee makes the decisions.

Participants at a scientific event
Discussing scientific contributions together.
The review process

From the first assessment to the revised file

Once contributions are assigned, reviewers read them, comment directly in the PDF and record their assessments. The coordinator then shares the committee’s decision and selected feedback with the authors. If needed, a revised version follows for another review.

Interactive example · fictional data
Review workspace Materials forum 2026 · Example event
Example
PAPER POOL · MATERIALS

A paper ready for review

Review team
PAPER 04

Designing aluminum alloys for recycling

Mara Beispiel · Elias Muster
Institute for Materials Examples

Manuscript_v1.pdf PDF · 6 pages
Pending
REVIEWER TEAM
A Reviewer A Review access
B Reviewer B Review access
EXAMPLE ASSESSMENT

Assess the paper

Fictional review criteria for this example:

  • Does the paper fit the topic?
  • Is the methodology sound?
  • Are the results clearly explained?
Initial rating 1–5
4 / 5

Start with the paper pool, reviewer team, and rating.

Guidelines and responsibilities

Prepare reviewer access and assessment

We set up reviewing around your event's responsibilities and schedule and agree with you whether it is open, single-blind or double-blind. The guidelines explain what reviewers should look for in their assessment.

Review groups and sessions

Reviewers are assigned to a review group covering specific sessions, so they see exactly the contributions they are meant to assess.

Guidelines and deadlines

The assessment criteria are set out in the guidelines. You also decide when reviewing starts and ends and when revisions are due.

Overall rating and comment

An optional overall rating from one to five complements the written comment. Individual ratings and their average appear alongside the contribution.

Files included in the review

Together with you, we decide which file types each process includes, such as abstracts, manuscripts or posters. Decisions can also be made separately for individual files.

PDF comments and annotations

Feedback at the relevant passage in the PDF

Reviewers read and comment on the PDF in the same viewer. Feedback stays linked to the contribution and the file being reviewed.

Notes at the relevant passage

Reviewers can highlight or strike through text. Comments and drawings point to specific places in the document.

Annotations linked to the file

Notes are saved with the review discussion. The viewer displays comments beside the PDF and identifies the person who wrote them.

Internal discussion and author feedback

Internal notes remain separate from communication with authors. The coordinator selects which comments and annotations to share with the decision.

Feedback for the revision

Authors can view the shared annotations in the PDF and refer to each note in context when revising their work.

Review status and file versions

Follow decisions and revisions

The scientific committee decides on the contributions. The coordinator records the outcome and shares the selected feedback with authors.

Status and individual decisions

The overview shows the current review status and each reviewer's decisions. This makes it clear which assessments have already been submitted.

File versions in view

The file history shows every submitted version. Decisions on an earlier version are marked as outdated, so it is clear which file a decision refers to.

Decision and feedback

Acceptance, a revision request, or rejection is recorded with the contribution. The coordinator shares the outcome and selected notes. Publishing a decision can trigger status notifications and emails.

Another review after revision

If changes are needed, authors submit an updated version. It can be reviewed again and then accepted or returned with further feedback.

From contribution to conference volume

Prepare reviewed contributions for publication

After reviewing, we agree with you on the final files for the program or publication. We can automatically compile the selected abstracts or manuscripts into a PDF volume with a cover, table of contents, and page numbers. We can issue a DOI on request.

Related services

Related services for reviewed contributions

After the decision, accepted contributions can be assigned to the program and published on the conference website or poster panel.

Abstract submission

Set up a call for papers, collect abstracts and files, and check presentations.
More about abstract submission Abstract submission

Conference website and web app

Show the program and abstracts on the website and in the web app, with a personal schedule.
More about the website and web app Conference website and web app

Poster panel

Show accepted posters in print, on digital panels and in the online gallery.
More about the poster gallery Poster panel
Plan your review process

How should reviewing work for your conference?

Tell us which contributions you need to review, who will assess them, and how your committee wants to make and communicate decisions. We will discuss the process and deadlines with you.